well, if the post is judged on overall merit, it is a fine post.

and I think what may have been happening is folks judging for the post itself, and not whether it is a post that fits within the guidelines for @dreemport

imagine you entered a pie into a cooking competition and a whole bunch of people thought the pie tasted wonderful and gave it a high mark, but they had forgotten the table your pie was on was the cake section and they should have been judging it as a cake, and not a pie.

like I said, it could be worthwhile to ask in the discord channel for clarification